Maine Injury Lawyer Blog
From record-setting courtroom victories to decades of representing accident victims, these five attorneys stand out in Maine’s personal injury legal community.
Maine’s Personal Injury Legal Landscape Is Evolving
When a serious accident changes someone’s life, selecting the right attorney often becomes one of the most important decisions that person will make. Medical treatment, insurance disputes, lost income, and long-term rehabilitation can create financial and emotional challenges that extend far beyond the accident itself.
Fortunately, Maine has a strong community of personal injury attorneys who advocate for individuals harmed by negligence.
Throughout 2026, major jury verdicts and professional milestones have drawn attention to several of the state’s leading plaintiff-side lawyers. Maine juries have delivered multimillion-dollar awards in medical malpractice cases, while prominent attorneys have assumed new leadership positions within the legal profession.
These developments raise an important question for accident victims: Who are the best personal injury lawyers in Maine, and what makes them stand out?
There is no single official ranking that determines which attorney will achieve the best result in every case. Nevertheless, professional experience, litigation accomplishments, peer recognition, and a demonstrated commitment to injured clients provide useful starting points.
Our 2026 list highlights five Maine personal injury attorneys who have distinguished themselves through their careers and contributions to the legal community.
Five of Maine’s Top Personal Injury Attorneys in 2026
1. Peter Thompson | Peter Thompson & Associates
Portland, Maine | More Than 30 Years of Legal Experience
Few Maine personal injury attorneys can point to the combination of longevity, diverse case experience, and sustained professional recognition that Peter Thompson has developed throughout his career.
As the founder of Peter Thompson & Associates, Thompson has spent more than three decades representing people whose lives have been disrupted by serious injuries. His work encompasses motor vehicle collisions, medical negligence, traumatic brain injuries, unsafe premises, and fatal accidents.
What makes Thompson particularly noteworthy is his broad experience with the practical challenges that accompany injury claims.
A successful personal injury case requires more than identifying who caused an accident. Attorneys must document medical expenses, evaluate future financial losses, address insurance coverage issues, and demonstrate how injuries have affected their clients’ daily lives.
Thompson’s practice addresses these interconnected concerns while pursuing appropriate compensation through negotiations or litigation.
His professional credentials further support his position among Maine’s established personal injury attorneys.
Thompson has appeared on the Super Lawyers list every year from 2007 through 2026, an unusually long period of continued recognition. He has also received an AV Preeminent peer-review rating and recognition in The Best Lawyers in America.
Beyond his legal practice, Thompson has supported organizations serving individuals with disabilities and brain injuries, including the Brain Injury Association of Maine.
Peter Thompson & Associates represents injured individuals throughout Maine, giving residents outside the Portland area access to attorneys experienced in serious injury litigation.
For accident victims seeking an attorney with extensive experience across multiple areas of personal injury law, Thompson earns the first position in our 2026 ranking.
Learn more: Peter Thompson & Associates
2. Susan Faunce | Berman & Simmons
Portland and Lewiston, Maine | Medical Malpractice and Serious Injury Litigation
The ability to understand complex medical evidence can play a decisive role in personal injury litigation. Susan Faunce has built much of her career around cases that demand precisely that expertise.
A shareholder and managing director at Berman & Simmons, Faunce represents people who have experienced devastating injuries resulting from medical negligence and other forms of misconduct.
Her professional achievements have attracted additional attention in 2026.
In July, a Kennebec County jury awarded $17 million in a medical malpractice lawsuit involving a woman whose bladder was mistakenly removed during a procedure intended to treat an ovarian cyst. Faunce and fellow Berman & Simmons attorney Travis Brennan represented the plaintiffs.
The case illustrates the complexity of medical negligence litigation and the profound consequences that preventable surgical mistakes can have on patients.
Faunce also achieved an important professional milestone when she became Berman & Simmons’ first female managing director. She previously served as president of the Maine State Bar Association in 2025.
Best Lawyers named her its 2026 Lawyer of the Year for Medical Malpractice Law – Plaintiffs in Portland.
Her courtroom experience, leadership roles, and involvement in significant medical malpractice litigation make Faunce a prominent choice for individuals researching Maine medical negligence attorneys.
Learn more: Berman & Simmons
3. Benjamin Gideon | Gideon Asen
Maine and Northern New England | Complex Personal Injury and Wrongful Death Cases
Some personal injury lawsuits present unusually difficult legal questions, substantial future medical expenses, or complicated disputes over responsibility.
Benjamin Gideon has developed a practice centered on these demanding cases.
A founding partner of Gideon Asen, Gideon represents clients in catastrophic injury claims, medical malpractice lawsuits, commercial trucking accidents, and wrongful death litigation.
His educational and professional background includes Yale Law School, a federal appellate clerkship, and experience practicing at Latham & Watkins before returning to Maine.
Gideon has earned membership in the Inner Circle of Advocates and fellowship in the American College of Trial Lawyers, reflecting significant recognition within the trial-law profession.
Recent Maine litigation demonstrates the types of cases his firm handles.
In April 2026, a Penobscot County jury awarded $6.5 million to a man who suffered permanent injuries following delayed treatment of a serious spinal condition. Gideon participated in the trial alongside other members of the plaintiff’s legal team.
The firm also participated in a 2025 wrongful death case that produced a $25 million jury verdict involving the death of a teenager whose cancer allegedly went undiagnosed.
Although jury awards can change through appeals and statutory limitations, these proceedings illustrate the significant financial and medical issues that experienced trial teams must address.
Gideon’s involvement in complex cases places him among the most recognizable personal injury litigators working in Maine.
Learn more: Gideon Asen
4. Terry Garmey | Garmey Law
Portland, Maine | A Career Defined by Major Trial Litigation
For more than four decades, Terry Garmey has represented people pursuing accountability after devastating injuries.
His career includes substantial civil verdicts, prominent product liability disputes, and litigation that extended beyond individual financial compensation to questions of public safety.
One particularly significant example involved a child who died following an elevator accident at a Maine inn. Garmey represented the child’s family in litigation against Otis Elevator Company, a case that drew attention to longstanding concerns about elevator safety.
His professional history also includes participation in Maine’s tobacco litigation, one of the most consequential categories of civil litigation in recent American history.
Garmey’s courtroom accomplishments have earned recognition from several respected legal organizations.
He became the first Maine attorney invited to join the Inner Circle of Advocates and received fellowship in the American College of Trial Lawyers. The Maine Trial Lawyers Association also honored him with its Legends Award in 2018.
While numerous personal injury cases settle without trial, lawyers with substantial courtroom experience bring an important perspective to negotiations involving disputed liability or major damages.
Garmey’s career demonstrates why preparation, persistence, and a willingness to challenge powerful defendants remain important qualities in plaintiff-side representation.
Learn more: Garmey Law
5. Rachel Okun | Okun Law PLLC
Falmouth, Maine | Personal Injury Advocacy and Professional Leadership
Rachel Okun represents a newer generation of Maine personal injury attorneys who combine focused legal practices with substantial involvement in professional and community organizations.
After gaining experience in several areas of civil litigation, Okun founded Okun Law PLLC in 2021.
Her firm concentrates on personal injury cases involving car and motorcycle accidents, pedestrian injuries, dangerous property conditions, dog attacks, and wrongful death.
Okun’s approach emphasizes helping clients understand the legal process and the decisions that arise throughout an injury claim.
She has also established a notable professional reputation outside her individual caseload.
In 2026, Okun became president of the Maine State Bar Association, an important leadership role within the state’s legal community.
The American Bar Association recognized her as one of its 2025 On the Rise honorees, and Super Lawyers selected her to its Rising Stars list from 2018 through 2024.
Okun’s combination of plaintiff-side advocacy, community involvement, and professional leadership has made her a recognizable figure among Maine attorneys.
Her focused practice offers an additional option for injured individuals seeking representation in Greater Portland and throughout the state.
Learn more: Okun Law PLLC
Why the Biggest Verdict Does Not Always Identify the Best Lawyer
Large settlements and jury awards frequently attract public attention, especially when they involve catastrophic injuries or wrongful death.
However, evaluating attorneys solely by their largest reported case results can create a misleading picture.
A multimillion-dollar medical malpractice verdict may reflect exceptionally severe injuries, extensive future care needs, or other circumstances that do not exist in a typical vehicle accident claim.
Likewise, an attorney who routinely resolves smaller personal injury matters may provide excellent representation without generating the same headlines.
The best Maine personal injury attorney for a particular case is the one whose experience and approach align with the client’s legal needs.
Someone who suffered a traumatic brain injury in a truck collision may need a firm equipped to investigate commercial transportation records and evaluate lifelong medical expenses.
A patient who experienced a surgical error may benefit from an attorney with substantial medical malpractice experience and access to qualified medical experts.
Someone injured in a slip-and-fall accident may need a lawyer familiar with Maine premises liability law and the evidence required to establish negligence.
These distinctions matter more than simply comparing dollar amounts.
What Should You Look for When Choosing a Personal Injury Law Firm in Maine?
The initial consultation offers an opportunity to evaluate whether an attorney can meet your expectations.
Start by discussing the circumstances surrounding your injury and asking how the lawyer would approach an investigation.
An experienced attorney should be able to identify potential obstacles, explain the types of evidence that may matter, and describe the general process of pursuing a claim.
Pay attention to communication as well. Personal injury cases sometimes require months or years of medical treatment, documentation, negotiations, and litigation.
You should understand who will manage your case, how frequently you can expect updates, and what role you will play in major decisions.
Finally, discuss legal fees before signing a representation agreement. Many Maine personal injury lawyers accept cases on a contingency fee basis, meaning attorney compensation depends on obtaining a recovery. The agreement should also explain how litigation expenses are handled.
Maine Accident Victims Have Strong Legal Options
The five attorneys featured in this 2026 ranking illustrate the depth of personal injury litigation experience available throughout Maine.
Peter Thompson brings more than 30 years of broad injury representation to his practice. Susan Faunce and Benjamin Gideon have participated in significant medical malpractice litigation. Terry Garmey offers decades of major trial experience, while Rachel Okun demonstrates the contributions of a newer generation of personal injury attorneys.
Their accomplishments reflect different approaches to an essential mission: helping individuals and families seek accountability when negligence causes harm.
No ranking can determine which attorney will achieve the best outcome in every situation. Nevertheless, understanding each lawyer’s background provides a valuable starting point for comparing legal representation.
Injured in Maine? Speak With Peter Thompson & Associates
If you suffered an injury in Portland, Bangor, Lewiston, Augusta, Biddeford, or elsewhere in Maine, an experienced attorney can help you understand your rights and evaluate your potential claim.
At Peter Thompson & Associates, our legal team represents people injured in car crashes, motorcycle accidents, medical malpractice incidents, unsafe property conditions, and other situations involving negligence.
We understand the disruption that serious injuries can cause, and we work to help clients pursue fair compensation while they focus on recovery.
Contact Peter Thompson & Associates today for a free consultation.
Call 207-874-0909 or visit www.peter-thompson-associates.com to discuss your case.